Honest Review Of The 7 Best Gardening Shoes 2021: An Extra Reason To Love Gardening


Garden works are associated with many unpleasant things: dirt, mud, water, heat, and various thorns. To feel comfortable during work, one needs to wear the proper footwear. Although you can wear your worn-off trainers or old-fashioned wellingtons, after a couple of hours of intensive work, you’ll realize that this is not the best choice. So, what shoes to wear when gardening? Well, if you spend at least one hour per week in a garden pulling weeds, watering plants, or ploughing, it’s time to buy gardening shoes and do the same work more comfortably.

Best Gardening Shoes: a Comparative Chart

BrandTypeMaterialOutsoleInsoleFitDurabilityWarranty
MuckBoots DailyShoesSynthetic + fabricRubber, non-slippery, ribbedNon-removableComply with expectations++1 year, limited
SloggersShoesNatural fully recyclable foamSemi-rigid, non-slippery, lug treadsAll-Day-Comfort removable insolesComply with expectations, full sizes only+++N/A
NORTYBootsRubberNon-slippery, lug treadsRemovable insoles for an improved arch supportRun large+30 days
Anywear ExactShoesSyntheticSynthetic, non-slipperyCushioned, with ventilation holesComply with expectations++N/A
Crocs Unisex SpecialistClogsEVA foamSynthetic, non-slipperyNo insoleComply with expectations+++N/A
Natural UniformsClogsEVA foamSynthetic, non-slipperyNo insoleRun large++N/A
Clogs StoreShoesEVA foamSynthetic, non-slipperyNo insoleComply with expectations++N/A
Crocs Women’s Jaunt ShortyBootsEVA foamRubber, non-slipperyNo insoleComply with expectations+++33 lbs
Evercreatures Women’s Rain BootsBootsRubberRubber, non-slipperyNo insoleComply with expectations+++N/A
Joules Women’s Wellibob Rain BootBootsRubberRubber, non-slipperyNo insoleComply with expectations+++N/A

How We Selected the Top Gardener Shoes?

To pick out the winners in the category of the best shoes for gardening and yard work we used a comprehensive approach. We’ve analyzed hundreds of customer reviews on Amazon and other major platforms. It helped us to determine the best-selling products and promising new offers. After that, we tested the chosen samples in the real-life conditions to assess their wearing comfort, durability, build quality, materials, and design. By the way, it turned out that some of the much-hyped brands are less brilliant than their cheaper counterparts. The result of our research is the list of top-seven models of best shoes to wear for gardening for men and women. Meet the winners!

Top-7 Shoes for Gardening in 2021: Our Choice

Here is our detailed review of the best shoes for gardening that were included in our final top-7 list. They all meet basic requirements for quality, durability, comfort, water- and mud resistance. All the models reviewed are currently available on Amazon, and most of them are awarded more than 4 stars.

The Original MuckBoots Daily Garden Shoe

Review

Muckboots Daily are an excellent unisex option for all types of outdoor activities. They are great for both mild winter and rainy summer. The ribbed sole is sturdy and thick enough to protect your feet from thorns and stones and flexible enough to provide comfort during working and walking even on sloping surfaces.

What we think

If you are searching all-purpose waterproof gardening shoes, MuckBoots can be a pretty good option. They allow doing all kinds of yard works and lawn works in a rainy weather. Mind that they are not for a hot weather – there are no vent holes and the material is  non-breathable.

PROS

  • lightweight and waterproof;
  • natural-rubber surface;
  • anti-slippery ribbed soles;
  • pull tabs at heels;
  • semi-flexible soles;
  • comfortable and easy to on and off.

CONS

  • non-ventilated;
  • not for hot weather;
  • some customers complain about sole cracking, although such cases are rare.

Sloggers 5113BP08 Rain and Garden Shoe with All Day Comfort Insole, Black/White Polka Dot Print

Review

Each pair of these Sloggers combines a perfect functionality with cute polka dot design plus (other color variations are available). They are made of a fully recyclable material, which makes them an eco-friendly option. The surface is completely waterproof, and the semi-rigid sole with a heavy lug tread provides an anti-slippery effect in muddy and dirty conditions. The removable “All Day” insole ensures an ultimate comfort.

What we think

We truly love both design and constructions of Sloggers. It is exactly what your feet need in autumn, rainy summer, and even mild winter. Be careful when choosing the size – they are available in full sizes only.

PROS

  • comfortable, lightweight, and waterproof;
  • very easy to clean;
  • an insole is removable and can be washed separately;
  • fully recyclable materials;
  • nice design;
  • can be worn in a mild winter or rainy summer;
  • made in the US.

CONS

  • non-breathable material;
  • available only in full sizes.

NORTY – Womens Ankle Rain Boots – Ladies Waterproof  Winter Spring Garden Boot

Review

To ensure the ultimate protection from tough weather conditions you need to purchase gardening shoes that are comfortable to wear, mud-, water-, and snow-resistant, and cover your feet at least from soles to ankles. NORTY rain boots meet all these requirements. Thanks to the special design of their treads, they ensure the ideal traction irrespective of the type of road surface. You can use these rubber shoes for gardening for any other outdoor activities.

What we think

The rain boots are lightweight and comfortable but they tend to run large. On the other hands, you can wear them with warm socks in winter. Some buyers complain about sole cracking.

PROS

  • perfectly protect from mud, dirt, water, and snow;
  • clever tread design ensures ideal traction;
  • an ankle-high design allows hassle-free walking in the puddles;
  • ensure the comfort of all types of outdoor activities;
  • warm and soft inside.

CONS

  • they run large;
  • there are reports about sole cracking.

Anywear Exact Work Shoe

Review

If you want to find the best cheap gardening shoes, try these Anywear clogs. They have a nice conventional design and protect your feet effectively from dirt, water and thorns. Cushioned insoles with ventilation holes provide an extra wearing comfort. The clogs themselves are very lightweight, so you don’t feel them if you have to work in the garden for hours, and their anti-slippery soles are great for walking and working in the muddy conditions.

What we think

The only small drawback of these wonderful clogs is squeaking, which must disappear over time. We love a wide selection of color solutions and soft removable insoles.

PROS

  • very comfortable and lightweight;
  • protect from mud, dirt, and water,
  • anti-slippery sole design;
  • removable ventilated insoles;
  • easy to wash.

CONS

  • fully synthetic materials;
  • they tend to squeak.

Crocs Unisex Specialist Clog

Review

We just couldn’t ignore the famous Crocs that are mentioned in all best gardening shoes reviews. Their Specialist model is available in black, navy, and white colors. These are classic unisex Crocs made of croslite with an improved arch support and a massaging footbed. Crocs are extremely lightweight, easy to wash, comfortable, and, finally, they have an anti-bacterial effect. Yard works and outdoor walks in summer get much more comfortable with these clogs.

What we think

There are many reasons to fall in love with original Crocs footwear. These clogs lack vent holes but croslite is very comfortable to wear even if the weather is hot.

PROS

  • the patented croslite material;
  • anti-microbial and anti-bacterial effect;
  • the back-strip prevents a foots’ slipping out;
  • anti-slippery soles;
  • easy to clean.

CONS

  • The Specialist model is not ventilated;
  • non-resistant to higher temperatures.

Natural Uniforms Ultralite Clog

Review

This is one of the most affordable brands of EVA-foam gardening shoes Amazon offers. They are appreciated by casual gardeners who need lightweight water-resistant footwear every day. These ultra-light clogs are soft and comfortable. They feature anti-slippery non-marking soles with an improved arch support. The great thing about the clogs is that they are made of top-quality EVA foam with an anti-bacterial effect.

What we think

A great price/quality ratio! The clogs are well-made and really comfy to wear but they run a bit large. 

PROS

  • made of EVA foam;
  • lightweight and very comfortable;
  • affordable clogs that can be worn every day;
  • very easy to wash.

CONS

  • non-breathable, no ventilation holes;
  • they run large.

Clogs Store Waterproof Rain and Garden Shoes

Review

An extremely light weight, innovative recyclable EVA foam, and neutral design make this Clogs Store option the best shoes for market gardening, working in the yard, and walking in a rainy and muddy weather. They reliably protect your feet from dirt, water, sand, and thorns. They are as light as air, so you can wear them all day long without getting tired. Needless to say they are 100% waterproof and anti-bacterial. Your feet remain dry and clean irrespective of the weather conditions and duration of your outdoor activities.

What we think

Cheap weather-resistant clogs that are must-haves for every gardener. We’ve found nothing to complain about, except for, may be, a bit too wide entrance. They don’t fit tight around ankles.

PROS

  • very easy to put and take off, comfortable to wear;
  • eco-friendly and fully recyclable EVA foam;
  • massaging footbed;
  • no smell after unboxing;
  • more affordable than many similar models.

CONS

  • they don’t fit tight against ankles;
  • non-resistant to higher temperatures.

Crocs Women’s Jaunt Shorty Boot

Review

Jaunt Shorty boots are made of genuine croslite, which means they are extremely lightweight, waterproof and easy to wash. You can wear them all day long without feeling tired. With Crocs boots, you’ll forget about the problem of “heavy legs” after hours of working in the garden. Tough rubber outsoles protect feet from thorns, mud, and water.

What we think

 These boots have all the benefits of croslite footwear. They are comfy and lightweight. Pull circles from both sides make them easy to on and off. The only small complaint is that they are a sort of narrow around the ankles.

PROS

  • EVA foam of high quality;
  • as light as a feather;
  • durable and easy to maintain;
  • have an anti-bacterial effect;
  • convenient pull circles.

CONS

  • expensive;
  • a bit narrow openings.

Evercreatures Women’s Rain Boots UK Brand Original

Review

These high rain boots come in over 10 various colors. Bright, lightweight, and 100% waterproof – they are made to color grey rainy days and bring some comfort into your life. The boots are made of real rubber, which makes them fully water-repellent. A non-slippery outsole is perfect for working in mud and water, and soft cotton lining adds comfort.

What we think

This is not the cheapest option around but the boots are worthy of it. If you need the ultimate protection from mud and water, you must try them. We absolutely love adjustable side straps that add convenience.

PROS

  • 100% waterproof;
  • soft and comfortable inside;
  • can be worn with warm socks or insoles;
  • non-slippery rubber outsoles;
  • very durable;
  • easy to maintain.

CONS

  • a bit expensive;
  • rubber is heavier than EVA-foam.

Joules Women’s Wellibob Rain Boots

Review

These 100% rubber boots are made to last. They are exceptionally well-made, durable, and provide the maximum comfort thanks to their waterproof outside and soft inside. A small (0.75 inches) heel and a thick anti-slippery outsole make the rain boots a perfect option for all types of garden works and long walks under tough weather conditions.

What we think

These stunning boots will make you love rain! We are absolutely charmed with both design and quality. With 13 unique color solutions available, you’ll find your favorite pair.

PROS

  • well-made and durable;
  • water-resistant;
  • 13 colors available;
  • all-rubber anti-slippery outsoles;
  • perfect for rainy weather.

CONS

  • a bit pricey;
  • heavy if compared to croslite options.

Verdict and Recommendations

With the right shoes gardening can become a real pleasure. The choice of the suitable footwear will depend on what works for shoes to wear while gardening you are engaged in. If you have to work in tough weather conditions, deal with mud and water, or walk in puddles, you should choose a pair of rubber boots. Good examples are NORTY Ankle Rain Boots or google for what brand is equal to Bogs gardening shoes.

For casual gardening in summer, clogs will do. These are classic Crocs or their cheaper analogs. Our pick is the Crocs Specialist model – lightweight, durable, and relatively inexpensive. An intermediate option is gardening shoes Target, MuckBoots, AnyWear Exact, or any similar brand. They are lightweight, comfortable, and provide a better protection than clogs. Most of them are unisex, but you can find men’s gardening shoes reviews and purely female designs too.

Other Garden Carers Are Reading:

✅ Trending

Outdoor Garden Design And Tips

✅ Home Design And Tips

✅ Garden Care Products

✅ Sustainable Living Products And Tips

✅ Plant Care And Products

✅ Bird Care

✅ Decluttering Tips

Recent Posts